newsletters don't convert (& maybe that's the point)


Hey, hey Reader,

I’ve been thinking a lot about customer newsletters lately.

Specifically, the monthly kind that B2B SaaS & EdTech companies send out.

I launched one this year for a client. It’s solid: a mix of educational content and product updates, thoughtfully written, well-designed, and genuinely useful.

But now I’m getting the inevitable question:
“How is it driving product engagement or activation?”

And I’ll be honest.

I’ve always been skeptical of monthly newsletters for exactly this reason. They’re time-consuming to produce, difficult to measure beyond opens and clicks, and often too infrequent to build any real momentum.

In my experience, newsletters work best as part of a broader nurture strategy, not as a direct conversion tool.

But the pressure to prove short-term ROI is real.

So here’s where I’ve landed (for now):

The case for newsletters is not found in conversions. It’s in conditioning.
Done well, newsletters create consistency. They give your brand a regular rhythm. They keep customers connected, even when they’re not actively using your product. And over time, they build trust so that when an update does land, your email is the one they open.

But that only works when a few things are true:

  • The content feels customer- and human-first, not company-first
  • It’s clear, concise, and not overloaded with CTAs
  • You send often enough to stay top of mind, but not so often it becomes noise

So if you're wondering whether to launch (or keep) your customer newsletter, consider:

  • Is it helping customers do something better?
  • Is it part of a longer customer journey or lifecycle strategy?
  • Do you have the systems in place to learn from it? Meaning you don’t send just to send?

That’s the lens I’m shifting toward now. Less “monthly news dump,” more “mini momentum-builder.”

Curious to hear how you approach this, too.
Have you seen newsletters move the needle? Or, do they fall flat in your org?

See you next Wednesday.

And as always , I'm rooting for you 👏.

Kelly

PS. Wanna really know what your buyer's need before they do?👇

Join Inside the Inbox: Turn your B2B Emails into District-Winning Deals. Get on the waitlist now.

Want to Get Un-Stuck with Your Marketing Strategy? Book a 1:1 hour-long sesh with me.

Get Your Case Studies Noticed with Case Study Blueprint. Buy now.

Say👋 on LinkedIn

Did a friend forward this email? Subscribe here.

191 Haines Avenue, PO Box 104, Barrington, NJ 08007
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Inside the Inbox: Turn Your Emails Into District-Winning Deals

Strip away distractions and shiny objects to deliver the email marketing results you need in EdTech. If you're a customer success manager, a marketer, a copywriter, or a founder, every Wednesday get weekly tips to reach and genuinely engage school district decision-makers.

Read more from Inside the Inbox: Turn Your Emails Into District-Winning Deals

Hey, hey Reader, Let’s talk welcome sequences. Specifically, the role they play in edtech marketing. If you've ever googled "best welcome email tips" and found yourself drowning in B2C advice ("Add urgency!" "Offer a discount!" "Convert them ASAP!"), you're in good company. When you're marketing to schools and districts, a welcome sequence isn’t the same conversion engine you'll find in B2C. It’s a first hello in a very s l o w dance. Your reader likely can’t buy right away. They may not even...

Hey, hey Reader, I’ve been helping a client move from what I generously call an ESP to a real-deal platform. As exciting as it sounds, most of our time hasn’t been spent designing email flows or writing copy. It’s been meetings. About forms...and fields...and data. Specifically: Where the current data lives What’s actually usable How to prevent garbage data from creeping back in Funny enough, this week, I stumbled on a Slack thread that felt eerily familiar. Marketers and ops folks were...

Hey, hey Reader, Ever feel like your emails get lost in the admin inbox abyss? School districts have a tiny window to make purchasing decisions, and if you’re not in their inbox at the right time… you’re out of sight (and out of budget). That’s why I put together the School Admin Monthly Priorities & Subject Lines Planner.... ...your step-by-step guide to sending the right emails at the right time in 2025. Inside, you’ll find: ✅ A breakdown of school admin priorities month by month ✅...