resist the urge to do this


Hey, hey Reader,

I wrote another batch of role-focused cold emails for a client last week.

During feedback, I saw the same note pop up over and over again when I referenced the company name:

“link to the homepage”

Now, I’m usually a nice, amenable person.

But clients don’t hire me just because I’m easy to work with. They hire me for my expertise.

So I pushed back.

Here’s why:

When you give readers too many options, you kill curiosity.

Every extra link dilutes urgency, muddies your CTA, and tanks your click-through rate.

(Absolutely add loads of links on your blogs/thought leadership pieces but avoid this in your emails.)

And if we're being honest, clicks aren’t even the goal.

You already know opens and CTRs don’t mean much.

If you see your open rates and CTRs skyrocket the second you hit send....

That’s usually security software or bots testing your links, not genuine human interest.

A click is only an indicator that someone was curious.

The real goal is to get them to act:

  • Stick around and explore your site
  • Fill out a form, book a demo, or start a trial
  • Move one step closer to becoming a customer

That’s what Beth O’Malley calls “Return on Impact”: measuring how email supports your bigger business goals, not just what it converts today.

Because we know a singular email is never going to convert a district deal; it just ain't.

So instead of sprinkling five links into a cold, warm, or hot email and hoping something lands, give them one clear action to take.

Then let your website (and your follow-up sequence) do the rest.

Pro tip: Review your email performance quarterly (instead of per send) and look for things like:

  • list growth
  • engagement
  • pipeline movement
  • quarterly conversions

And if you want to get even cleaner email indicators, delete those inactive subs (I just removed 15 today).

That’s how you find out which emails strengthen your strategy and business outcomes.

That's it for me. See you next Wednesday.

And as always, I'm rooting for you,

Kelly

Whenever you’re ready, here are a few ways I can help you win more district deals.

  1. EdTech Email Alchemy — Join the waitlist (Re-opening this fall).
  2. Strategy Power Hour — Book a 1:1 hour-long sesh with me (And, if we decide to continue our work together, that first hour’s on me.)
  3. Case Study Blueprint — Turn ‘nice story’ into ‘district proof’. Buy now.
  4. Say👋 on LinkedIn — Connect with me there.

Did a friend forward this email? Subscribe here.

191 Haines Avenue, PO Box 104, Barrington, NJ 08007
Unsubscribe · Preferences

EdTech Email Alchemy: Turn Your Emails Into District-Winning Deals

Strip away distractions and shiny objects to deliver the email marketing results you need in EdTech. If you're a customer success manager, a marketer, a copywriter, or a founder, every Wednesday get weekly tips to reach and genuinely engage school district decision-makers.

Read more from EdTech Email Alchemy: Turn Your Emails Into District-Winning Deals

Hey, hey Reader, December is always a time where I think about my year's highs and lows business-wise, and plan for my 2026. The highs have been launching my email marketing course, growing my client-base, and working with companies that are doing incredible things. The lows and what I plan on changing is offloading the stuff I hate doing like Canva slides (I hired a teacher-friend to make them for my course), invoicing, and the work-from-home-isolation. In that spirit, I've been thinking a...

Hey, hey Reader, A client of mine shared the sentence every marketer loves to hear: “That email you wrote booked several demos.” And the best part was that this email didn’t ask for a demo in the call to action. There was no sales language, pitch, ‘schedule a call’. Zip, nada, nothin’. Just a simple, story-driven email built on a framework I come back to again and again. So today for our final Anti-Black Friday series, I want to give you that framework. 1. Start with one person and one...

Welcome to Day 2 of the Anti-Black-Friday, Reader, Today we're using a simple dipstick test to see whether your messaging works. If your messaging feels fuzzy or flat, it’s usually because you’re too close to the product. It's the Febreze “noseblind” effect. You’ve lived with the product so long you don’t notice what your audience instantly smells. Inside your company, the scents differ: Sales talks urgency and ROI Marketing talks benefits Product talks functionality Leadership talks vision...